Tennessee prison chief resigns, executions halted after failed Christa Pike execution
Botched lethal injection attempts leave Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike in critical condition, prompting the resignation of the state’s prison chief. Gov. Bill Lee postpones all executions through 2026 as an independent review begins. UC Berkeley Law professor John Yoo analyzes the legal controversy and previews key cases as the Supreme Court prepares to kick off its new term.
NEWYou can now listen to articles!
The execution of a double murderer who bailed one of his victims out of jail only for the man to be shot dead — and then killed his sister when she went looking for him — has been put on hold after Tennessee’s botched attempt to lethally inject Christa Pike for her role in the “satanic” torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in Knoxville in 1995.
Gov. Bill Lee halted the death penalty across the state for the rest of the year — but there was only one scheduled, the Dec. 3 execution of convicted double murderer Gary Wayne Sutton.
His uncle and co-defendant, James Dellinger, died of natural causes on death row in 2023.
FORMER KNOXVILLE POLICE CHIEF SAYS INVESTIGATORS ARE STILL HAUNTED BY COLLEEN SLEMMER’S MURDER 31 YEARS LATER
Gary Wayne Sutton pictured in a mugshot taken on Nov. 11, 2025, at the Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Tennessee. (Tennessee Department of Correction)
Sutton has maintained his innocence — but in separate trials, he was convicted in the murders of Tommy Griffin and Connie Branam, a brother and sister who were killed on Feb. 21 and 22, 1992.
Sutton, who months earlier had beaten up Griffin’s brother, went drinking with Dellinger and Griffin at a bar called Howie’s Hideaway on Feb. 21, 1992, according to court records reviewed by Digital.
After they left, they got in a fight, and Sutton and Dellinger left Griffin on the roadside. He encountered a passing driver who flagged down a police officer, according to court documents.
CHRISTA PIKE’S BOTCHED LETHAL INJECTION TAKES FOCUS OFF VICTIM, JEOPARDIZES EXECUTION: FORMER POLICE CHIEF
Christa Gail Pike appears remotely from Deborah K. Johnson Rehabilitation for her hearing in Knox County Criminal Court in Knoxville, Tenn., on Aug. 11, 2026. (USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect)
The responding officer reported that Griffin was “on the verge of tears” and shirtless with “scrapes and scratches” on his upper body and a cut behind is ear. Griffin claimed he had gotten into “an argument with some friends, who were not really his friends,” according to court records.
He declined to give specifics and was arrested for public intoxication. Sutton and Dellinger showed up at the police station to bail him out around 8:30 p.m. and were told to come back later. They did at about 11:30 p.m., bringing a flannel shirt, according to court documents.
A half-hour later, witnesses reported hearing three gunshots in the area where his body would later be found. He’d suffered a shotgun blast to the head.
Emergency vehicles arrive at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville, Tenn., on Sept. 30, 2026. Pike had not been declared dead when witnesses were asked to leave the room they were in. (Denny Simmons/The Tennessean/USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images)
LAWYERS, EXPERTS URGE TENNESSEE GOVERNOR TO COMMUTE CHRISTA PIKE’S SENTENCE AFTER BOTCHED EXECUTION
The next day, Griffin’s sister, Branam, went to Howie’s Hideaway with Sutton and Dellinger. She told the server she was looking for her brother. Her body was later found in her scorched car — so badly burned that the forensic pathologist could not determine whether she had been alive when the fire started. Detectives did recover a .303 cartridge that matched a rifle found at Dellinger’s home.
SIGN UP TO GET THE LATEST TRUE CRIME NEWS
Sutton’s supporters have criticized the case as circumstantial. It remains unclear who shot Griffin and how exactly Branam died.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE FROM THE FOX TRUE CRIME HUB
Sutton’s execution was scheduled for Dec. 3 but has been put on pause due to the state’s failure to carry out Pike’s death sentence last week.
Pike’s botched execution was the second in Tennessee this year after executioners couldn’t find a suitable vein for fellow condemned inmate Tony Carruthers in May.
DEATH ROW INMATE UNCONSCIOUS ON VENTILATOR AFTER BOTCHED EXECUTION FOR TEEN’S KILLING: ATTORNEYS
A split image shows Christa Pike at her murder trial in 1995, left, and Colleen Slemmer, the young woman she was convicted of torturing and killing, on the right. (Reuters)
GOT A TIP?
While what’s next for Pike remains unclear as she is in an undisclosed hospital for treatment following two doses of lethal injection drugs that failed to kill her, Lee said Carruthers would not face execution again for at least a year after his scheduled death in May was canceled.
LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST
Pike, who was hospitalized in critical condition, is the first person to have survived the administration of lethal injection drugs, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, a nonprofit that tracks capital punishment across the U.S.
GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL
In 2014, an Oklahoma inmate named Clayton Lockett initially survived the injection but died of a heart attack while still inside the chamber, according to the center.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE APP
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
