Bachelor Nation’s Caila Quinn found her final rose in husband Nick Burrello.
“I feel really lucky because I feel like I wasn’t meant to go on the show to find love there,” she exclusively told Us Weekly in January 2020. “I was meant to go on the show to find Nick. If I wasn’t on the show, I wouldn’t ever have met him because I would never have been a blogger and that’s who introduced us and set us up on our first date. So, I think everything happens for a reason and I thank God every day.”
Nick and Caila — who appeared on Ben Higgins’ season 20 of The Bachelor — said “I do” in May 2021 after reworking their wedding plans due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The pair went on to welcome daughter Teddi and son Christian in March 2023 and August 2024, respectively.
In April 2025, a content creator shared a series of accusations against Nick, claiming he was unfaithful to Caila with “a couple different people.” She denied the allegations at the time, while Nick remained silent regarding the fidelity claims.
In July 2025, Quinn announced they were expecting their third child.
Scroll down to see Caila and Nick’s love story from the beginning:
October 2017
Caila confirmed her relationship with Nick in October 2017.
September 2018
Caila opened up about first crossing paths with Nick in a September 2018 blog post on her website. “The walls of the Wren were lined with hopeful singles, but to our table tucked away in the back of the bar you came without hesitation,” she wrote. “The polite man you are… you introduced yourself to my bevy of girlfriends, saving me for last. ‘Pleasure to meet you,’ I blushed in the dark. He was even cuter in person.”
She continued, “My girlfriend Olivia had briefly pulled up a picture earlier that night in an effort to set us up. I really wasn’t even looking for someone at the time, having been in New York for over two years – I thought all the good ones had deserted. But Olivia sold me with, ‘I feel like you guys are similar. He’s a thoughtful listener.’ So from one party to this rustic bar, I trusted my friend.”
January 2020
Us exclusively confirmed in January 2020 that Nick popped the question to Caila. The former reality TV star explained that Nick planned a “very romantic, elaborate evening,” including a stay at a suite at the Ritz Carlton.
May 2021
Nick and Caila tied the knot in Sarasota, Florida, at the Ringling Museum of Art in May 2021. The pair were originally set to exchange vows in Lake Como, Italy, but canceled their nuptials because of the pandemic. They also reworked their second wedding plans in Ohio due to COVID-19 protocols.
“I am so excited to announce that Nick and I are finally married,” she told Us at the time. “It was truly a dream day. … Wish it didn’t have to end!”
September 2022
Caila exclusively announced to Us that she was pregnant with their first child. “I put a new camel sweater on our dog Ash and tucked the pregnancy test in it. When Nick called Ash to come sit with him on the couch, the pregnancy test fell out and Nick shouted, ‘No way!’ in pure shock — and joy, of course!” she said.
March 2023
The couple welcomed their first child, daughter Teddi, in March 2023. “I kind of brought the name up to Nick and it was one of a few we were considering, but I’ve always just loved the name,” she explained to Us at the time.
February 2024
Nick and Caila announced in February 2024 that they were expanding their family. “Well… looks like there is another ‘Minnie me’ coming in August ✨🥹,” the twosome captioned their joint Instagram post at the time, alongside a video of the couple and daughter Teddi posing in Minnie and Mickey Mouse clothes underneath the Magic Kingdom.
“So excited for Teddi to become a big sister!! We are soaking in every second bringing her to Disney for the first time,” she continued. “Also, enjoying this trip before next time we have to do it with a double stroller 😂.”
August 2024
The pair announced the birth of son Christian in August 2024. “Our hunky man decided to come early ✨ Love you so much already Christian Anthony Burrello ♥️ 9 lbs 6 oz,” Nick and Caila wrote in a joint Instagram post at the time. Born Friday, August 23rd at 7:08pm. Been resting and trying to recoup, thank you to all of our family and friends for the well wishes ✨.”
April 2025
A content creator alleged that there are posts on Bachelor Reddit discussing Nick’s alleged unfaithfulness to Caila.
“The post was made by somebody that he was seeing. In a sense they were texting with each other. It was a relationship over text. He met this person on Grindr and he is dating a trans woman,” the content creator claimed, alleging that Nick claimed in the threads that it was “not the first time he’s cheated on Caila.”
Caila, for her part, set the record straight in the comments section of the TikTok. “WTF is this…” she wrote, alongside a laughing emoji. “This isn’t true. And my husband doesn’t go on business trips. This is a joke. No one believe these rumors. This is FALSE.”
July 2025
Caila shared she and Nick were expecting their third child after denying the cheating rumors about him.
“Baby number three is on the way this December! Soon, we’ll have 3 under 3, and we are so happy,” she told People. “Thank you for your love and support during this special time. We’re soaking in every precious moment together as a family before this exciting next chapter begins.”
December 2025
Calia gave birth to baby No. 3, a son named Grayson.
“After a smooth c-section we’ve been soaking in all of the scrunchie cuddles with baby boy,” she wrote via Instagram. “Took us a moment to share the news as we couldn’t decide until the last moment on how to spell his name.”
