The Trump administration has asked Nature Medicine magazine to investigate whether former top US health officials Dr. Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins secretly drafted a key paper that dismissed the theory that COVID-19 leaked from a Chinese lab.
In a letter obtained by The Post, National Institutes of Health (NIH) director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya asked the journal to open a “formal, independent investigation” into “alleged ghostwriting and unacknowledged substantive contributions.”
Bhattacharya’s letter was first reported by The Daily Telegraph.
The March 2020 paper, titled “The Proximal Origin of SARS-Cov-2,” argued against the so-called “lab leak” theory in favor of the idea that the deadly virus spread naturally from animals to humans.
Records obtained by congressional investigators show the paper was drafted four days after Fauci, then the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) director, and Collins, then the NIH director, held a conference call with its credited authors.
Bhattacharya’s letter argues Fauci and Collins should have been identified as co-authors and calls for the journal to consider retracting the paper if an “investigation is not possible or correction is inadequate.”
According to the NIH boss, both Fauci and Collins were sent a draft of the paper on Feb. 4, 2020, three days after the teleconference. A March 6 email from one of the credited authors, Kristian Andersen, cited a later version of “Proximal Origin” and thanked Fauci, Collins and British scientist Jeremy Farrar for their “advice and leadership.”
On the same day Fauci and Collins were sent a draft of “Proximal Origin,” Farrar emailed the Americans that his opinion was split “50-50” on whether the virus emerged from a lab, while another co-author of the paper — Edward Holmes of the University of Sydney in Australia — was “60-40 lab.”
However, other co-authors of the paper intervened to argue against blaming Chinese authorities for unleashing a virus that caused hundreds of thousands of deaths, even if they did so accidentally.
“Given the s–tshow that would happen if anyone serious accused the Chinese of even accidental release,” Dr. Andrew Rambaut of the University of Edinburgh wrote in a Feb. 2, 2020, Slack message to Andersen, Holmes and a fifth co-author, Dr. Robert Garry, “my feeling is we should say that given there is no evidence of a specifically engineered virus, we cannot possibly distinguish between natural evolution and escape so we are content with ascribing it to natural process.”
“Yup, I totally agree that that’s a very reasonable conclusion,” Andersen responded. “Although I hate when politics is injected into science — but its [sic] impossible not to, especially given the circumstances.”
“An accusation that nCoV-2019 might have been engineered and released into the environment by humans (accidental or intentional) would need to be supported by strong data, beyond reasonable doubt,” added Dutch virologist Dr. Ron Fouchier, who took part in the conference call but was not credited as an author of “Proximal Origin,” in an email that same day.
“It is good that this possibility was discussed in detail with a team of experts. However, further debate about such accusations would unnecessarily distract top researchers from their active duties and do unnecessary harm to science in general and science in China in particular.”
A July 2023 report by the GOP-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic revealed that the article was almost rejected by Nature Medicine for not sufficiently disproving the lab leak theory.
“[T]he possibility must be considered as a serious scientific theory (which is what we do) and not dismissed out of hand as another ‘conspiracy’ theory,” Andersen emailed one of the journal’s editors on Feb. 20, 2020. “We all really, really wish that we could do that (that’s how this got started), but unfortunately it’s just not possible given the data.”
The FBI and Energy Department have since concluded with low confidence that COVID-19 did leak from a lab in the Chinese city of Wuhan, where the first cases of the virus were reported in late 2019.
Andersen has insisted that neither Fauci nor Collins played any role in writing the paper, but previously testified that Fauci spoke directly with him by phone on Jan. 31, 2020, and “specifically suggested considering writing a peer-reviewed publication” on COVID origins.
Fauci also suggested edits to the paper through Farrar, according to emails obtained by Republicans on the subcommittee.
